Partner Caleena S. Braig shared advice for companies considering workplace vaccine, testing, or mask mandates after a Supreme Court decision with Corporate Compliance Insights reporter Henry Kronk.

The interview was featured in a Corporate Compliance Insights article, Supreme Court Ruling Likely Spells the End for Vaccine-or-Test Federal Mandates at Large Businesses, But Numerous Caveats Apply, was published on January 14. An excerpt from the article is below.


The Supreme Court conservative majority held ranks to temporarily stay an OSHA standard that would have made large employers require their employees get vaccinated or wear a mask and test regularly. 

While the policy has been up in the air since it was introduced in November, experts believe this will be the de facto final say on the matter. But that verdict is not certain. Other circuits continue to consider the mandate. OSHA may come up with new standards. State governments, meanwhile, have leeway to put their own measures in place.

CCI reached three experts in employment law to get their comment on the stay and what it means for employers. 

Caleena Braig, partner at law firm Moye White:
Notably, in granting the stay, the U.S. Supreme Court held in a 6-3 decision that the challenge to the ETS is likely to succeed on the merits because OSHA lacked the authority to issue the ETS mandate. The court explained that OSHA is allowed to “set workplace safety standards, not broad public health measures.” Because the risk of contracting COVID-19 is not only in the workplace but also in many other public settings, COVID-19 “is not an occupational hazard.” Thus, the court held that allowing OSHA to broadly regulate “the hazards of daily living” would expand OSHA’s authority beyond what Congress allows.

While likely indicative of what may come, the Supreme Court’s decision is not the final say. Instead, the court directed the Sixth Circuit to consider the substantive validity of the ETS. But, with the stay in place, employers have additional time to prepare for compliance should courts uphold the ETS, which appears unlikely. Because of the court’s decision, OSHA may issue a new or limited ETS on the subject matter.

Further, the court’s decision does not affect state and local COVID-19 vaccination and testing requirements. Employers are not in the clear yet and should continue to monitor updates until there is a final resolution on this matter.

Read the full article in Corporate Compliance Insights.


About Moye White LLP

Moye White LLP is a business law firm serving clients throughout the United States and internationally, with offices in Colorado and Georgia. The firm provides legal representation across a wide variety of transactional and litigation matters, offering strategic, business-oriented counsel to public, private, and governmental clients in complex business and real estate transactions and disputes. As one of the earliest national law firms to achieve B Corp certification, Moye White meets rigorous standards of social and environmental performance, transparency, and accountability. For more information, please visit moyewhite.com or contact Managing Partner Thomas List at 303-292-2900 or tom.list@moyewhite.com.

Patrick Akers

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsLitigation

J. David Arkell

Attorney

Alternative Dispute ResolutionConstructionLitigationAdvanced Energy

Evelyn A. Ashley

Of Counsel

Business and CorporateEmploymentIntellectual PropertyInternational Transactions
and Dispute Resolution
Mergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsStartupsPrivate EquitySoftware and Technology

Valerie D. Barton

Attorney

Business and CorporateEmploymentIntellectual PropertyMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsFinancial ServicesPrivate Equity

James Belgum

Attorney

Business and CorporateConstructionLitigationInsurance

Jack W. Berryhill

Attorney

Alternative Dispute ResolutionLitigation

Kelsey R. Bowers

Attorney

Business and CorporateConstructionEmploymentLitigationInsurance

Allen N. Bradley

Attorney

Business and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsStartupsTaxTrusts and EstatesAdvanced EnergyPrivate EquitySoftware and TechnologySustainability

Caleena S. Braig

Attorney

ConstructionEmploymentLitigation

James R. Cage

Attorney

ConstructionEmploymentIntellectual PropertyLitigationFinancial ServicesInsurance

Vikrama S. Chandrashekar

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsLitigationAdvanced EnergyBrewing and DistillingMedia and Entertainment

Frederic K. “Jerry” Conover

Of Counsel

Alternative Dispute ResolutionLitigation

Amy M. DeColibus

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingCommercial Real Estate LendingConstructionMergers and AcquisitionsReal Estate

Rebecca B. DeCook

Attorney

Administrative LawEmploymentLitigationAdvanced EnergyCommunicationsPrivate Equity

Matt Dillman

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate

Bobby W. Dishell

Attorney

Business and CorporateCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingMultifamily and CondoReal EstateAdvanced EnergyCannabisSustainability

Tom Dolphin

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate

Keely C. Downs

Attorney

Multifamily and CondoReal EstateAdvanced EnergySustainability

Georginne Dudash

Attorney

Real Estate

Andrew T. Flynn

Attorney

EmploymentLitigationInsurance

Erik K. Foster

Of Counsel

Commercial Real Estate LeasingConstructionMultifamily and CondoReal Estate

Paul R. Franke, III

Co-Chair, Litigation Section

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsBusiness and CorporateLitigationReal EstateCommunicationsFinancial ServicesPrivate Equity

Heidi J. Gassman

Co-Chair, Business Section

Business and CorporateCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingConstructionReal EstateTrusts and Estates

Garrett Graff

Attorney

Business and CorporateInternational Transactions
and Dispute Resolution
Mergers and AcquisitionsReal EstateStartupsBrewing and DistillingFood and BeverageManufacturingCannabis and Hemp

Charles Greenhouse

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsLitigationReal Estate

Scott P. Greiner, LL.M. (Tax)

Attorney

Business and CorporateTaxTrusts and Estates

Arthur K. Griffin

Attorney

Business and CorporateCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingMultifamily and CondoReal EstateBrewing and Distilling

Lynne M. Hanson

Attorney

Business and CorporateFranchise and DistributionIntellectual PropertyMergers and AcquisitionsFinancial ServicesFood and BeveragePrivate Equity

Nick R. Herrick

Attorney

ConstructionEmploymentLitigationInsurance

Allison M. Hester

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsLitigation

Patrick J. Hickey

Attorney

EmploymentLitigationReal EstateAdvanced Energy

Jessica R. Hunter

Attorney

Business and CorporateIntellectual PropertyBrewing and DistillingFood and Beverage

Karla Jaramillo

Attorney

LitigationCannabis

William F. Jones

Attorney

Franchise and DistributionIntellectual PropertyLitigationReal EstateTrusts and EstatesBrewing and DistillingFood and BeverageInsuranceManufacturing

Danielle M. Kane

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentConstructionMultifamily and CondoReal EstateSustainability

David J. Katalinas

Attorney

Business and CorporateFranchise and DistributionMergers and AcquisitionsReal EstateFood and Beverage

John W. Kellogg

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsBusiness and CorporateFranchise and DistributionMergers and AcquisitionsAdvanced EnergyManufacturingPrivate EquityBlockchain Technology

Craig J. Knobbe

Attorney

Business and CorporateFranchise and DistributionMergers and AcquisitionsReal EstateBrewing and DistillingFood and Beverage

Ezra Kramer

Attorney

Business and CorporateEmploymentIntellectual PropertyMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsAdvanced EnergyPrivate EquitySoftware and TechnologyBlockchain TechnologySustainability

David A. Laird

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsConstructionLitigationReal EstateFinancial Services

Jennifer Knight Lang

Attorney

ConstructionLitigationReal EstateInsurance

Brendan Leanos

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsBusiness and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsStartupsFinancial ServicesPrivate Equity

Chris Levkulich

Attorney

Business and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsMultifamily and CondoReal EstateStartupsTaxTrusts and EstatesPrivate Equity

Eric B. Liebman

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsConstructionEmploymentLaw Practice, Regulation, Ethics, and Professional LiabilityLitigationReal EstateTrusts and EstatesAdvanced EnergyFinancial ServicesInsurance

Thomas M. List

Managing Partner

Commercial Real Estate LeasingConstructionEmploymentLitigationReal Estate

Stephanie D. Loughner

Attorney

Business and CorporateEmploymentReal Estate

Charles F. Luce, Jr.

Attorney

Intellectual PropertyLaw Practice, Regulation, Ethics, and Professional LiabilitySoftware and Technology

Joseph W. Mark

Attorney

Alternative Dispute ResolutionBusiness and CorporateLitigation

Chris McCall

Attorney

Business and CorporateEmploymentIntellectual PropertyLitigationSecurities and Capital MarketsCannabis

Courtney A. McShane

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate

Jacob Millis

Attorney

Business and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsTax

Jason T. Moilanen

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate

John E. Moye

Retired

Business and CorporateLaw Practice, Regulation, Ethics, and Professional LiabilityMergers and AcquisitionsFinancial Services

Dean Nakayama

Executive Director

Edwin A. Naylor

Attorney

Business and CorporateIntellectual PropertyMergers and AcquisitionsManufacturing

Elizabeth J. Peros

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate DevelopmentReal Estate

Merc Pittinos

Co-Chair, Real Estate Section

LitigationReal Estate

Tasha J. Power

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate

Dean Richardson

Co-Chair, Litigation Section

Franchise and DistributionLitigationReal Estate

Lucas T. Ritchie

Attorney

Business and CorporateEmploymentLitigationRegulatory and Enforcement DefenseAdvanced EnergyFinancial ServicesInsurancePrivate Equity

Zaki Robbins

Co-Chair, Business Section

Business and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsAdvanced Energy

Nikki Roberts

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal EstateFinancial Services

David C. Roos

Attorney

Business and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities & Capital MarketsFinancial Services

Amy H. Ruhl

Attorney

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate LeasingMultifamily and CondoReal Estate

Christopher W. Scolari

Attorney

Trusts and EstatesAdvanced Energy

Erin L. Scott

Attorney

Litigation

Dominick Sekich

Attorney

Business and CorporateReal EstateAdvanced EnergyBrewing and DistillingCommunicationsFood and BeverageManufacturingMedia and EntertainmentSoftware and TechnologySustainability

Tanya A. Sevy

Attorney

Administrative LawConstructionEmploymentLitigation

Lorni Sharrow, LL.M. (Tax)

Attorney

Trusts and Estates

Michael R. Siavage

Of Counsel

Business and CorporateIntellectual PropertyMergers and AcquisitionsSecurities and Capital MarketsSoftware and Technology

Jennifer L. Stenman

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate LeasingMultifamily and CondoReal EstateAdvanced EnergyFinancial Services

Timothy M. Swanson

Attorney

Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ RightsLitigationFinancial Services

Jake J. Tiernan

Co-Chair, Real Estate Section

Commercial and Real Estate LendingCommercial Real Estate LeasingMultifamily and CondoReal EstateBrewing and Distilling

Daniel C. Wennogle

Attorney

ConstructionLitigationReal Estate

Edward D. (Ted) White

Attorney

Alternative Dispute ResolutionBusiness and CorporateMergers and AcquisitionsReal EstateAdvanced EnergyFinancial ServicesPrivate EquitySustainability

Thomas Witt

Attorney

Commercial Real Estate DevelopmentCommercial Real Estate LeasingReal Estate